Football History

The 1921 season of the American Professional Football Association (APFA), later to become the NFL, remains a fascinating and controversial chapter in the league's formative years. While the Chicago Staleys officially hold the championship title, the story surrounding their victory is rife with debate, centering on the impact of exhibition games and the persuasive power of George Halas. This season exemplifies the challenges and ambiguities that plagued the early days of professional football, where clear-cut rules and consistent practices were still a work in progress.

Want to catch up on our series of posts and podcasts on Pre-Super Bowl NFL Champions? Check it out here NFL Champions.

The controversy revolves around the Buffalo All-Americans and their scheduling choices. In 1921, the nascent league struggled with standardized schedules and consistent competition. Teams often played various games, and the definition of a "league game" versus an "exhibition" was frequently blurred. Buffalo's decision to participate in an exhibition game proved pivotal in the championship's ultimate outcome. As discussed in historical football podcasts, this seemingly innocuous decision significantly impacted their official record. Had that exhibition game not been played, or had it been counted towards their league record, Buffalo's standing, and potentially the championship outcome, could have been dramatically different. The very fact that such a decision could have such a profound effect underlines the fluid and, at times, chaotic nature of the early NFL.

Ken Crippen's insights shed light on how these exhibition games, though often overlooked, played a crucial role in determining championship recognition in 1921. In those early years, teams relied on revenue from any and all games, including exhibitions, to survive. These games weren't just for practice but essential for financial stability. While perhaps financially beneficial, Buffalo's choice to play an exhibition ultimately cost them dearly in the championship race.

While Buffalo's fate was intertwined with their scheduling decisions, George Halas and the Chicago Staleys capitalized on the situation. Halas, a shrewd strategist and influential figure in NFL history, played a key role in securing the championship for his team. His persuasive arguments regarding the interpretation of league standings and the impact of exhibition games proved decisive. It’s been suggested that Halas's ability to navigate the league's often murky rules and regulations, combined with his persuasive skills, ultimately swayed the decision in Chicago’s favor.

The 1921 season serves as a compelling reminder of the importance of exhibition games in professional football's early history. These games weren't merely warm-ups; they were vital for a team's survival and, as the Buffalo/Chicago situation illustrates, could influence the championship outcome. With its controversial championship decision, the story of the 1921 season underscores the challenges faced by the early NFL. It highlights the complex interplay of on-field performance, scheduling decisions, and the influence of key figures like George Halas.

-1921 Chicago Staleys season

-Owner George Halas,

-Dutch Sternaman

-Head coach George Halas

-Home field Staley Field (Decatur),

-Cubs Park (Chicago)

-Results

-Record 9–1–1 APFA

-(10–1–1 Overall)

-League place 1st APFA

-APFA standings

W L T PCT PF PA STK
Chicago Staleys 9 1 1 .900 128 53 T1
Buffalo All-Americans 9 1 2 .900 211 29 L1
Akron Pros 8 3 1 .727 148 31 W1
Canton Bulldogs 5 2 3 .714 106 55 W1
Rock Island Independents 4 2 1 .667 65 30 L1
Evansville Crimson Giants 3 2 0 .600 89 46 W1
Green Bay Packers 3 2 1 .600 70 55 L1
Dayton Triangles 4 4 1 .500 96 67 L1
Chicago Cardinals 3 3 2 .500 54 53 T1
Rochester Jeffersons 2 3 0 .400 85 76 W2
Cleveland Tigers 3 5 0 .375 95 58 L1
Washington Senators 1 2 0 .334 21 43 L1
Cincinnati Celts 1 3 0 .250 14 117 L2
Hammond Pros 1 3 1 .250 17 45 L2
Minneapolis Marines 1 3 0 .250 37 41 L1
Detroit Tigers 1 5 1 .167 19 109 L5
Columbus Panhandles 1 8 0 .111 47 222 W1
Tonawanda Kardex 0 1 0 .000 0 45 L1
Muncie Flyers 0 2 0 .000 0 28 L2
Louisville Brecks 0 2 0 .000 0 27 L2
New York Brickley Giants 0 2 0 .000 0 72 L2


1921 Chicago Staleys season. (2025, February 3). In Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1921_Chicago_Staleys_season

February 15th has been a significant date in the history of American football, marked by moments of triumph, strategic decisions, and the celebration of legendary figures. This day has witnessed events that have shaped the sport, from groundbreaking achievements on the field to pivotal decisions made in the boardroom.

On this day, some of the biggest names in football have etched their names into the annals of the game, leaving a lasting impact on the sport's landscape. Additionally, February 15th serves as a day to honor the birthdates of several Hall of Famers, individuals whose contributions have elevated the game to new heights.

This article will delve into the specific events that have unfolded on this date, highlighting the individuals and teams that have made their mark on February 15th in American football history.

November 3rd has consistently been a date marked by significant moments in the rich tapestry of American football history. From the gridiron exploits of legendary players to the historic achievements of storied franchises, this day has delivered countless memorable events.

As we delve into the annals of the sport, we'll revisit the feats of those who have left an enduring legacy. We'll explore the triumphs and challenges of iconic figures and teams, as well as honor the birthdays of Hall of Famers whose contributions continue to inspire generations. Additionally, we'll commemorate a pivotal moment in the evolution of football safety, as players took a significant step towards protecting themselves on the field.

Join us as we journey through time, reliving the excitement, the drama, and the pure joy that has made November 3rd a special day for football enthusiasts.

---

November 18th has been a date filled with memorable moments in American football history. From historic upsets to record-breaking performances, this day has seen its fair share of gridiron excitement.

Throughout the years, legendary players and teams have etched their names into the annals of football history on this day. Whether it's a dramatic comeback, a dominant performance, or a milestone achievement, November 18th has consistently delivered thrilling action and unforgettable plays.

In addition to witnessing remarkable feats on the field, November 18th has also been a day to celebrate the birthdays of several football greats who have left an enduring legacy on the sport. These Hall of Fame inductees have inspired countless fans and continue to be revered for their contributions to the game.

---

November 11th has been a date of significance in the annals of American football, marked by both historic achievements and the celebrations of legendary figures. This day has witnessed moments that have reshaped the sport, etched into the memories of fans and players alike. From record-breaking performances to pivotal victories, the gridiron has seen its share of drama and excitement on this particular date.

Beyond the on-field action, November 11th has also been a day to honor the legacies of those who have made indelible contributions to the game. Several Hall of Famers were born on this day, their birthdays serving as a reminder of the immense talent and dedication that has shaped the sport's history. These individuals, through their extraordinary skills and unwavering commitment, have inspired generations of players and fans.

In this edition we discuss Jim Thorpe's coming out party against Harvard, Lamar Jackson's record setting performance as well as many more HOF Legendary stories.

---

November 14th has been a date of significance in the annals of American football, marked by both historic achievements and somber reflections. The gridiron has witnessed moments of triumph and tragedy on this day, forever etching the names of legendary players and teams into the sport's lore.  

From record-breaking performances to heartbreaking losses, November 14th has seen it all. The day has also been a time to honor the legacies of football's greatest figures, as several Hall of Famers were born on this date. Their contributions to the game continue to inspire generations of fans and players alike. As we delve into the events of this day, we'll revisit the stories of those who have left an indelible mark on the sport we love.

December 11th has been a date marked by significant events in the annals of American football. From historic performances to pivotal moments that shaped the sport, this day has witnessed a range of actions by some of the most iconic figures and teams in the NFL.

Whether it's the exploits of legendary players or the strategic maneuvers of legendary coaches, December 11th has been the stage for some of the most memorable plays in football history. From record-breaking performances to unexpected upsets, this day has consistently delivered thrilling moments that have captivated fans and left an enduring legacy.

Beyond the on-field action, December 11th has also been a day to celebrate the lives of some of the greatest football minds. Several Hall of Famers were born on this day, their birthdays serving as a reminder of their immense contributions to the sport and their enduring impact on football culture.

The 1935 NFL season marked a pivotal moment in the league's burgeoning history, showcasing a rapidly evolving strategy and popularity. While the nation grappled with the lingering effects of the Great Depression, professional football offered a welcome escape, a spectacle of grit and determination. This season, however, was dominated by the rise of a team that would etch its name into the annals of NFL lore: the Detroit Lions.

Under the astute leadership of coach Potsy Clark, the Lions, then just a few years removed from their relocation from Portsmouth, Ohio, had assembled a formidable squad. Their offense, spearheaded by Dutch Clark's powerful running and quarterback Bill Shepherd's strategic passing, proved a force to be reckoned with. Their defense, anchored by Ernie Caddel and Lloyd Thomas, was equally tenacious, capable of stifling even the most potent offenses.

The Lions' regular season was a testament to their dominance. They compiled a 7-3-2 record, securing the Western Division title and earning the right to host the NFL Championship Game. Their opponent, the New York Giants, led by the legendary Steve Owen, presented a formidable challenge. The Giants, known for their innovative T-formation offense, were eager to prove their own championship mettle.

The championship game, played on December 15, 1935, at the University of Detroit Stadium, was a hard-fought contest. The Lions' defense proved the decisive factor, effectively neutralizing the Giants' offensive threats. While the game was not a high-scoring affair, it showcased strategic brilliance and physical prowess. The Lions' relentless defensive pressure and timely offensive plays ultimately secured a 26-7 victory.

This triumph marked the Detroit Lions' first NFL Championship, a watershed moment for the franchise and the city of Detroit. It solidified their status as a dominant force in the league and provided a much-needed boost of morale during a challenging economic period. The 1935 Lions' victory was not just a win on the scoreboard but a symbol of resilience and determination, a testament to the power of teamwork and strategic execution. The 1935 season and championship game remain a significant chapter in the NFL's rich history, a reminder of the league's enduring appeal and the enduring legacy of the Detroit Lions.

---

The 1957 NFL season saw the Detroit Lions and San Francisco 49ers tied atop the Western Conference. A playoff game on December 22nd at Kezar Stadium in San Francisco would decide the divisional champion. The 49ers, led by quarterback Y.A. Tittle, jumped out to a commanding 27-7 lead. However, the Lions, sparked by quarterback Tobin Rote, staged a remarkable comeback.

Detroit's defense stiffened, forcing turnovers, while the offense found its rhythm. Running back Tom Tracy powered the ground game, scoring two crucial touchdowns. The Lions' relentless pursuit of victory culminated in a thrilling 31-27 comeback win. This victory propelled the Lions to the NFL Championship game, where they would defeat the Cleveland Browns 59-14, securing their third NFL title in six seasons.

49ers fans were sick to their stomachs after losing such a commanding lead, others were literally having ailing bellies. While the game itself left many 49ers fans feeling metaphorically sick, with the Lions winning 31-27 after the Niners blew a massive lead, the front page of the next day’s paper was all about the fans who were literally sick to their stomachs — from some bad deviled egg sandwiches.

A San Francisco Examiner story on December 23rd, 1957, detailed how at least 50 fans, primarily members of the visiting Pacific Grove High School band, fell ill with suspected food poisoning after consuming sandwiches at the game. The incident overshadowed the thrilling on-field action, with the city's health department launching an investigation into the source of the outbreak.

It was quickly determined that contaminated deviled egg sandwiches were the culprit. Despite the band members playing their halftime show "despite their almost unanimous queasiness," many were forced to seek medical attention. The incident served as a stark reminder of the importance of food safety, particularly in large-scale events, and led to scrutiny of the 49ers' food preparation and distribution protocols.

---

Much of what we are reminded of about the legendary running back Jim Brown was from his NFL playing days in Cleveland. Brown was an equally fantastic colleague in football at Syracuse University.

Brown, in 1956, had a season where his rushing yards per game read something like 197 yards, 162, 155, 154 & 151 yards! He ended up with 986 yards for the season, ranking him third in the nation and giving him the nod for unanimous All-America status for the Orangemen.

But that wasn’t it for “First Down Brown’s” accolades, though, as he also kicked for Syracuse. This is evident at the Colgate game in 1956 when Jim scored six touchdowns and kicked seven extra points. That was 43 points in a 61-7 Cuse victory. Jim Brown won on the ballot to be enshrined into the College Football Hall of Fame in 1995, and the University retired the number 44. The Cleveland Browns wasted no time making Jim their first-round pick in the 1957 NFL Draft.