The Victory That Healed: Marshall’s Improbable Return

For a grieving community in Huntington, West Virginia, September 25, 1971, was more than just a college football game—it was the first step on a long road to healing. It had been just over ten months since the devastating plane crash that claimed the lives of 75 members of the Marshall University football team, coaches, and staff. Against all odds, a new team, a group of freshmen and a few walk-ons, took the field at Fairfield Stadium for their home opener against the Xavier Musketeers.

The atmosphere was electric with emotion, a mix of profound sorrow and desperate hope. The game itself was a back-and-forth defensive struggle. With Marshall’s new “Young Thundering Herd” trailing 13-9 in the final minute, hope seemed to be fading. But the team, led by head coach Jack Lengyel, refused to give up. With a little over a minute left on the clock, Marshall’s offense took the field for one final drive.

The miraculous moment came with just seconds remaining. Quarterback Reggie Oliver, a freshman who had just turned 18, launched a 13-yard pass to tight end Jack Crabtree. Crabtree secured the touchdown catch, sending a wave of relief and disbelief through the stadium. The improbable win was sealed with a two-point conversion, making the final score 15-13.

The victory was more than just a number on a scoreboard. It was a powerful statement of resilience, a testament to the human spirit’s ability to persevere. It was a moment of pure joy for a city that had endured unimaginable tragedy, proving that the heart of the Thundering Herd still beat strong.