Football History

---

The podcast episode features an engaging conversation between Darin Hayes and Timothy P. Brown, centered around the intriguing figure of Walter Eckersall, a notable yet often forgotten quarterback from the early days of American football.

Eckersall is an interesting figure from the early gridiron that helped shape the game we know today in multiple facets: as a player, coach, official, and media personality.

Of course, this discussion all stems from Tim's original article titled: Booklet Review:Walter Eckersall's How to Play Football.

The audio-only podcast of the discussion can be found at: Uncovering Football's Past: The Legacy of Walter Eckersall.

Who is Walter Eckersall

Walter Eckersall was a legendary figure in early 20th-century American football. A three-time All-American quarterback for the University of Chicago, he led the Maroons to an undefeated season and the national championship in 1905, famously snapping Michigan's 56-game winning streak.  

Eckersall's impact extended beyond his playing career. He became a prominent sportswriter for the Chicago Tribune and a highly respected football official, officiating numerous high-profile games. His contributions to the game earned him a place in the College Football Hall of Fame.

We have much more on this important person from football's past. For more on his story check out

More on Walter Eckersall

.

This Story on Walter Eckersall

The episode begins by examining how each generation of players learns the game from esteemed mentors, setting the stage for a deep dive into Eckersall's life and career. Timothy paints a vivid picture of Eckersall's time as an All-American quarterback at the University of Chicago in 1906, a period when the forward pass was just beginning to emerge. The discussion highlights how Eckersall excelled not as a passer but as a strategist and athlete, influencing the game through his understanding and adaptability.

As the conversation unfolds, Timothy reveals the duality of Eckersall’s career, transitioning from a player to a respected sports writer and referee. This unique path not only showcases Eckersall's versatility but also reflects the interconnected nature of sports media and officiating during that era. The hosts discuss how Eckersall officiated significant games, including Rose Bowls, and the trust that players and fans had in him, despite the blurred lines between his various roles. This discussion leads to a broader commentary on the evolution of the game and how the role of statistics and analysis has transformed over the years, making the past seem distant yet vital to current football narratives.

Takeaways

-Darin Hayes and Timothy P. Brown discuss the history of football and its notable figures.

-Walter Eckersall was a significant pre-forward pass quarterback and a smart strategist.

-Eckersol's dual role as a writer and referee showcases the unique blend of professions in early football.

-Timothy P. Brown emphasizes the importance of preserving football history through storytelling and research.

-The podcast highlights the evolution of football and how players adapted to new strategies over time.

-Listeners are encouraged to engage with football history through Brown's substack site, Football Archaeology.

The episode ultimately serves as a tribute to the unsung heroes of football history, encouraging listeners to delve into the past and recognize the contributions of figures like Eckersall. Tim’s insights foster a greater appreciation for the foundations of the sport and emphasize the importance of preserving its history. The rich discussion not only educates but also inspires a sense of nostalgia for football’s roots, reminding us of the diverse personalities that have shaped the game into what it is today. Each story discussed reinforces the significance of understanding football's heritage and the impact of those who came before us in the sport.

---

The Notre Dame Box offense, popularized by Knute Rockne in the 1920s and 30s, revolutionized the game of American football. As discussed in a recent Pigskin Dispatch podcast featuring Timothy Brown of Football Archaeology, this formation was much more than just a static alignment; it was a dynamic and adaptable offensive weapon.

Rockne’s system employed a shifting backfield, creating a strategic chess match against opposing defenses. Players would move and reposition themselves before the snap, disguising intentions and forcing defenses to adjust, often incorrectly. This constant motion created confusion and opened up opportunities for both running and passing plays.

An in-depth exploration of the Notre Dame box offense reveals its transformative impact on American football. This episode features Timothy P. Brown, who articulates the historical context of the formation, tracing its origins to the University of Chicago and the innovative coaching of Amos Alonzo Stagg. The hosts delve into the intricacies of the offense, examining its unique player alignment and the strategic use of shifting motions, which were designed to deceive opposing defenses and create advantageous plays.

-What is the Notre Dame Box Offense

The Notre Dame Box is not an adaptation of the single-wing formation. The Box shift was derived before the single-wing was used, and considerable success was achieved in college and professional football. It was a staple of Knute Rockne's Notre Dame teams and Curly Lambeau's Green Bay Packers in the 1920s and 30s. Having played for Rockne, Lambeau brought the formation to the NFL after learning it from the legendary coach. Rockne, in turn, had learned it from Jesse Harper, taught by Amos Alonzo Stagg.

This formation positioned two ends and four backs in a box-like arrangement. A key characteristic was its often unbalanced line, with the center positioned near the weak side rather than directly in the middle. Teams would align initially in a T formation before shifting into the box. Unlike the traditional single-wing, the Notre Dame Box featured a balanced line and a halfback, typically the "wing" in the single-wing, positioned closer to the formation with the option to shift out. These modifications created a more symmetrical, less predictable alignment, facilitating runs to either side of the line. The halfback also became a more potent running threat, and the quarterback, usually a blocker in the single-wing, became a viable passer thanks to the center's ability to snap the ball directly.

The Notre Dame Box emphasized deception through frequent backfield shifts and motion rather than relying solely on the raw power typical of the single-wing. Teams often favored this formation if they lacked an actual "triple threat" tailback crucial for single-wing effectiveness. Rockne's genius lay in his sophisticated use of backfield movement, shifts to confound defenses and his adaptation of the formation for passing plays. While initially conceived as a powerful running formation, with seven players aligned on one side of the center and only two on the other, Rockne transformed it into a more versatile and unpredictable offensive weapon.

-Podcast Episode

As the dialogue unfolds, we gain insights into the tactical advantages of the Notre Dame box, particularly its capacity for misdirection and adaptability. The hosts discuss how this offense, characterized by a balanced line and fluid player movements, allowed for a diverse range of plays that challenged traditional defensive strategies. Furthermore, the conversation reflects on the historical evolution of football rules and how these changes influenced the development of offensive formations over time.

The episode culminates in a thoughtful reflection on the legacy of the Notre Dame box offense, inviting listeners to appreciate its foundational role in the evolution of football tactics. By understanding this formation's mechanics and historical significance, we gain a deeper appreciation for the continuous innovation that defines the sport.

The podcast highlighted the Notre Dame Box's innovative nature, delving into its player rotations' intricacies. Brown explained how Rockne strategically rotated players based on the specific play being called. This allowed for specialized skill sets to be utilized at the point of attack, maximizing the effectiveness of each play. The episode also explored the key differences between the Notre Dame Box and other prevalent formations of the era, such as the single wing. While both formations utilized misdirection and deception, the Notre Dame Box’s emphasis on pre-snap movement and versatile player roles distinguished it.

Listeners gained valuable insights into the mechanics of the offense, learning how the shifting, blocking schemes, and play options all worked in concert. The podcast discussion, featuring Darren Hayes and Timothy Brown, elucidated how this offensive system gave Notre Dame a significant competitive edge, contributing to its legendary status in college football history. The Notre Dame Box wasn’t just a formation; it was a philosophy, a testament to Rockne's innovative mind, and a pivotal chapter in the evolution of offensive football.

---

The episode presents a captivating examination of American football’s intersection with historical events, mainly focusing on a train journey taken by a football team in 1941 amidst the backdrop of World War II.

Timothy Brown from FootballArchaeology.com guides us through the meticulous details of this journey, which served as a conduit for understanding the broader implications of sports during an era marked by conflict and uncertainty. The narrative unfolds with a vivid description of the logistics involved in the travel, emphasizing the stark contrast between contemporary travel methods and the painstaking arrangements of yesteryear. This historical perspective not only enchants the listener but also serves as a reminder of the communal spirit and camaraderie shared amongst the players during these extended travels.

This information comes from his original post titled: All Aboard for 1941 Minnesota at Washington .

Also check out our podcast version of the tale: Exploring the 1941 Train Trip of Minnesota at Washington.

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around the coaching prowess of Bernie Bierman, whose remarkable accomplishments during the 1930s laid the groundwork for the Minnesota football program. The episode reflects on Bierman’s strategic choices during the game against Washington, particularly his decision to prioritize a robust defensive lineup. This choice exemplifies the tactical mindset prevalent during the time, where limited substitution policies dictated game strategies and influenced the outcomes of matches. The podcast further explores how the war affected player availability and the evolution of game rules, shedding light on the underlying dynamics that shaped the sport and its participants during this pivotal period in history.

Also on the trip was another football legend.

-Bruce Smith, nicknamed "Boo," was a standout American football halfback best known for winning the Heisman Trophy in 1941. Here's a concise summary of his career:

College Dominance:

-He played for the University of Minnesota Golden Gophers, contributing to their back-to-back national championships in 1940 and 1941.

-In 1941, he earned the Heisman Trophy, solidifying his status as the nation's top college football player.
He was a consensus All-American in 1941.

Professional Career:

-Following his college success and service as a U.S. Navy fighter pilot during World War II, he played in the NFL.

-He played for the Green Bay Packers (1945–1948) and the Los Angeles Rams (1948).
Legacy:

-Smith's legacy extends beyond his athletic achievements. He is remembered for his character and sportsmanship.
He was inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame in 1972.

-His number 54 was the first retired by the Minnesota Golden Gophers.

-His Heisman trophy acceptance speech was given just after the attack on Pearl Harbor, giving it a unique place in history.

Finally, the podcast culminates in a thoughtful discourse on the long-lasting effects of World War II on sports travel, delineating how the transition from rail to air travel revolutionized the logistics of team movement. The episode poignantly articulates the end of an era characterized by the romance of train journeys, which fostered a sense of unity among teams and created an intricate tapestry of experiences that defined the sport. As we reflect on these historical narratives, it becomes evident that the legacy of this transformative period continues to resonate within the modern landscape of football, inviting listeners to appreciate the rich heritage that informs the present-day game.

---

The podcast episode presents a compelling dialogue between Darin Hays and Timothy P. Brown, who dives into the historical complexities of college football programs that have experienced declines or outright cancellations. Brown, known for his expertise on football history through his work at FootballArchaeology.com, provides a thoughtful analysis of the interplay between football programs and their respective stadiums, particularly focusing on Catholic universities. As Hays sets the stage, he emphasizes the importance of remembering these programs and their legacies, inviting listeners to reflect on the broader implications of their histories.

Of course, this discussion all stems from Tim's original article titled: Stadium Size, Football Dropper - Catholic Univ.

The audio-only podcast of the discussion can be found at: Decline of Catholic U.

In a detailed exploration, Brown shares intriguing anecdotes about various schools, including Catholic University, which once had a vibrant football culture. The conversation highlights the significance of stadium size and capacity as indicators of a program's success or failure. Brown recounts how many schools, during the 1920s, sought to emulate the success of Notre Dame by investing in football, leading to the construction of sizable stadiums. However, as the conversation unfolds, it becomes clear that these investments did not guarantee long-term sustainability. Brown attributes the decline of many programs to a combination of factors, including financial constraints, demographic shifts, and resource limitations faced by urban universities. He reflects on how the events of World War II drastically impacted college athletics, leading institutions to reassess their commitment to football amidst manpower shortages and budgetary pressures.

The dialogue also addresses the contemporary landscape of college football, where the challenges of urban institutions persist. Brown discusses how land constraints and high operational costs continue to hinder football programs at schools located in densely populated areas. Despite these challenges, he offers a glimpse of hope as he points to a growing trend of D3 schools reinstating football programs as a strategic initiative to attract students. This episode ultimately serves as a rich narrative that intertwines historical insights with current realities, making it a valuable resource for anyone interested in the evolution of college football and its cultural significance.

Takeaways:

-The episode discusses the history of college football programs that have dropped or de-emphasized their football teams, focusing on the reasons behind these decisions.

-Timothy P. Brown explores the significant impact of stadium size on football programs and their sustainability over time.

-The podcast highlights the shift in Catholic universities' investment in football due to the influence of Notre Dame's success in the 1920s.

-Budget constraints and manpower shortages are key factors leading to the cancellation of football programs in various universities.

-The discussion includes how urban universities face unique challenges, such as land constraints, making it difficult to maintain football programs.

-Catholic University, which dropped its football program during WWII, later revived it in 1977, showcasing the evolving landscape of college sports.

---

Darin Hayes and Timothy P. Brown engage in a rich exploration of the history of player numbering systems in American football, a topic that reveals much about the sport's evolution.

Of course, this discussion all stems from Tim's original article titled: Factoid Feast I.

The audio-only podcast of the discussion can be found at: The Mystery of Football's Numbering: What Could Have Been.

The episode opens with Brown discussing the lack of a standardized numbering system prior to 1940, highlighting how players could choose any number they desired, leading to a chaotic situation on the field. Brown references a pivotal article written by Bob Balfe, which proposed a systematic approach to numbering, suggesting that backs wear numbers 1 through 4 while linemen should be designated numbers 5 through 11. This notion, while innovative, was not adopted until the NCAA established its own rules in 1941, which categorized players based on their positions and assigned specific number ranges accordingly.

The discussion delves into the practical implications of these numbering conventions, particularly in the context of officiating and game strategy. As football evolved into a two-platoon system, the need for clarity in player identification became crucial. Brown explains how the established numbering system aids officials in determining eligibility for passing plays and how it has become an integral part of the sport's infrastructure. The conversation also touches on the historical resistance to change by certain coaches who preferred more traditional methods, leading to entertaining anecdotes about teams that defied the norm by utilizing unique numbering schemes. This backdrop serves not just as a historical account but also as a reflection on how football has adapted over time, balancing tradition with the need for modernization.

Listeners are treated to a blend of historical facts, insightful commentary, and engaging stories that paint a vivid picture of American football's past. Hayes encourages listeners to visit footballarchaeology.com for more in-depth exploration of these topics, emphasizing the importance of understanding the historical context of the game. The episode thus serves not only as an informative piece on numbering systems but also as an invitation to appreciate the rich tapestry of football history, highlighting the contributions of individuals like Bob Balfe and Timothy P. Brown in preserving and sharing these fascinating narratives.

Takeaways

-The podcast discusses the evolution of player numbering in American football, highlighting its history.

-Timothy P. Brown explains Bob Balfe's proposed numbering system for football players from 1940.

-The NCAA standardized football player numbering in 1941, influencing how players are identified today.

-The discussion covers the rationale behind different numbering systems for various player positions.

-There was a time when players wore four-digit numbers, showcasing historical resistance to standardization.

The podcast also touches on the potential for future changes in numbering conventions.

---

Timothy Brown joins Darin Hayes to spotlight the significant yet often overlooked contributions of Henry Mitchell McCracken to the safety and evolution of American football. McCracken, who became NYU's chancellor in the late 19th century, played a pivotal role in advocating for safer rules in the sport during a time when football was facing scrutiny for its dangers.

Of course, this discussion all stems from Tim's original article titled: Stadium Size, Football Droppers, and Deemphasizers: NYU .

The audio-only podcast of the discussion can be found at: Henry McCracken Contributions.

Following the tragic death of a player during a game, the NYU Chancellor galvanized university leaders to convene and develop new regulations, ultimately leading to the formation of what is now the NCAA. The discussion delves into McCracken's legacy, including his influence on the establishment of halls of fame in the United States and his efforts to reform the game. Join us as we explore these fascinating historical insights and uncover the impact of McCracken's work on modern college football.

The conversation unfolds as Darin Hayes and Timothy Brown recount the historical landscape of football in the early 1900s, shedding light on the challenges and dangers the sport posed to its players. Timothy elaborates on the culture of college athletics at that time, where university presidents and chancellors, like McCracken, wielded significant influence over the direction of sports programs. The episode paints a vivid picture of the educational values intertwined with athletics, as faculty members played a crucial role in governance, leading to a system that prioritized student safety amidst the chaotic nature of early football games. The narrative details how McCracken's response to a fatal accident during a game exemplified the urgent need for reform in college football, ultimately resulting in a collaborative effort from various universities to establish safer playing conditions. This historical reflection not only honors McCracken's contributions but also invites listeners to consider the ongoing evolution of sports governance and safety in today's athletic landscape, drawing parallels between past and present.

Takeaways

-The podcast discusses the contributions of Henry Mitchell McCracken to football safety and history.

-Timothy Brown highlights McCracken's role in establishing the first Hall of Fame in America.

-McCracken's advocacy led to significant changes in football rules after a player was killed.

-The episode emphasizes how college sports governance was once more influenced by university presidents.

-The origins of the NCAA can be traced back to McCracken's initiatives in the early 1900s.

-Listeners learn about the historical context of college football's evolution and its challenges.

---

The narrative unfolds around the historical encounter between Penn State and Notre Dame, marking their first clash on the football field. I engage in a detailed examination of the circumstances leading up to the 1913 game, emphasizing both teams' relatively modest standings prior to their ascendance in collegiate football. My personal bias as a Notre Dame enthusiast is evident, yet I strive to maintain an objective lens while discussing the significance of this matchup. The episode provides a platform to reflect on the transformative journey of both programs, from their nascent stages to their eventual prominence in the sport.

This information comes from his original post titled: The First Notre Dame-Penn State Game.

Timothy P. Brown and I engage in a spirited dialogue about the broader implications of this game, including the societal and cultural contexts of American football during the early 20th century. We discuss the impact of coaching philosophies and the evolution of playing styles that characterized the game at that time. The reference to the football landscape of the era, especially the religious affiliations of many institutions and their influence on the game, adds a rich layer to our discussion. I highlight the innovative strategies that coaches like Jesse Harper employed, which would lay the groundwork for future developments in college football strategies.

Ultimately, the discussion serves as a recounting of a specific game and a reflection on how historical narratives shape our understanding of contemporary college football. I encourage listeners to consider the broader implications of this history and its relevance to the current landscape of the sport, as well as to engage with the memories and traditions that continue to define these iconic programs.

-Takeaways

-The inaugural meeting of the Nittany Lions and the Fighting Irish occurred in 1913, marking a significant event in college football history.

-Both Notre Dame and Penn State have storied football programs that were not always as prominent as they are today.

-The first game between Notre Dame and Penn State took place when both teams were relatively lesser-known and unestablished in the national football scene.

-Darin Hayes and Timothy P. Brown delve into the historical context and significance of this classic college football matchup in their podcast.

-The podcast provides insights into college football's evolution and highlights team prominence's changing nature over the decades.

-Listeners are encouraged to explore footballarchaeology.com for further historical tidbits and insights related to the sport.

---

Put down does not always have such a negative connotation as we use it in modern English, especially on the Gridiron.

The episode presents a comprehensive discourse on the pivotal yet underappreciated role of the kicking holder in American football. Engaging in a detailed dialogue with Timothy Brown, we traversed the historical nuances that define this crucial position. The discussion commenced with an inquiry into the significance of the holder, a figure who often remains in the shadow of more celebrated players. Timothy articulated the fascinating evolution of terminology associated with this role, revealing that the designation 'holder' did not emerge until the late 19th century, with prior references indicating a more rudimentary understanding of the position, such as 'the placer.' This linguistic evolution not only illustrates the shifting dynamics of the game but also highlights the historical context in which these changes occurred.

This information comes from Tim's original post titled: Holders And Other Put Downs.

Defining the Role of a Holder in American Football

An American football field goal holder is a crucial specialist on the field goal unit. Their primary job is to receive the snap from the center, secure the ball with the laces facing outward and tilted slightly forward, and present it cleanly for the kicker to strike. The holder must have quick hands, excellent catching ability, and the composure to handle errant snaps under pressure. They also act as a secondary protector for the kicker.

The exploration further delves into the complexities of early football, particularly during significant matches such as Michigan's road trip in 1883. We examined how the Intercollegiate Football Association instituted rule changes that confused teams, particularly regarding the holder's position and responsibilities during kickoffs. The discussion illuminated the practical challenges faced by players in that era, including the absence of artificial tees and the necessity for a human holder to stabilize the ball on often uneven playing surfaces. This historical perspective contextualizes the holder's role within the game's mechanics and emphasizes the broader themes of adaptation and innovation that have characterized football throughout its history.

Our dialogue encapsulates the essence of football's evolution, underscoring the importance of every player's role, no matter how seemingly minor. The holder emerges as a symbol of the collaborative spirit inherent in team sports, reminding us that even the most understated positions contribute to the intricate tapestry of the game. By the end of our conversation, we had fostered a newfound appreciation for the holder's significance, enriching our understanding of American football's storied past.

---

Darin Hayes and Timothy B. Brown embark on a historical journey exploring the fundamentals of kicking in football as they existed in 1923. This enlightening episode provides a detailed examination of the era's kicking techniques, equipment, and the overall strategy involved in the kicking game. Tim shares intriguing anecdotes from a rare publication by Wilson Athletic, which sought to rival the established Spalding brand in sports literature. The pamphlet reveals that drop kicks were the norm for field goals and extra points, highlighting the skill and precision required by kickers of that time.

The conversation stems from Tim's Tidbit titled: The Fundamentals of Kicking in 1923

You can also enjoy the audio podcast at: Discovering Football's Roots: Kickoff Techniques from 1923 or on your favorite podcast provider.

The discussion delves into the various techniques and challenges players face, including the importance of proper alignment and the difficulties posed by less reliable snapping methods. Tim also explains how the drop kick allowed for strategic advantages, creating uncertainty in play for opposing teams. This episode serves not only as a history lesson but also as a tribute to the artistry of kicking, showcasing how these historical practices have evolved into the modern kicking game we witness today.

Takeaways

-The podcast discusses the evolution of kicking techniques in American football, particularly focusing on the year 1923.

-Timothy B. Brown shares insights from a 1923 pamphlet detailing the fundamentals of kicking in football.

-Drop kicks were more common in 1923, with teams often lacking practice and good snapping techniques.

-Kickers in the past used dirt mounds for kickoffs due to the absence of tees.

-The history of onside kicks reveals a surprising lack of attempts during early football games.

-Kick return strategies evolved significantly and were influenced by rules established to limit wedge formations.

Additionally, the episode examines the evolution of game rules concerning kicking, such as the introduction of the 10-yard requirement for kickoffs, which aimed to enhance player safety. Tim reflects on the rarity of onside kicks during the early days of football, suggesting that the sport's ethics and strategies have undergone significant transformations. By the end of the episode, listeners gain a profound appreciation for the complexities of football history and its impact on the present-day game.

---

An engaging exploration of football's past unfolds as Darin Hayes and Timothy Brown delve into the intriguing history of tackling dummies. This episode captures the innovation and necessity behind these training tools, which have become staples on practice fields across America. Brown's insights reveal how the early dummies, created by football pioneers Stagg and Cumnock, were rudimentary yet revolutionary, reflecting the sport's evolution in safety and technique. The episode discusses the initial designs, which were often unrefined and made from whatever materials were available, highlighting the creativity and resourcefulness of early football coaches.

Of course, this story is based on Tim's Tidbit titled: Hanging Out With The Dummies

There is an audio only podcast version available of the discussion url=https://player.captivate.fm/episode/2009f0dc-2602-476f-84a9-3c9672d5d342/][/url]Timothy Brown Uncovers the Origins of Football's Tackling Dummies[/url]

Throughout the episode, Hayes and Brown discuss the significance of tackling dummies in reducing injuries and teaching proper techniques. Brown notes that as the game intensified, so did the need for effective training methods that could simulate real-game situations without the associated risks. The duo reflects on the various designs that have emerged, from the traditional rag-filled dummies to the sophisticated, high-tech models used in today's practices. This narrative not only educates listeners about the technical aspects of tackling training but also weaves in personal anecdotes and historical context, making it a compelling listen for football enthusiasts and history buffs alike. The episode serves as a reminder of how far the sport has come and the ongoing efforts to make football safer for future generations.

Takeaways

-The history of tackling dummies dates back to 1892, invented by Amos Alonzo Stagg and Arthur Cumnock.

-Enjoy some great footage of 1925 use of the equipment of tackling dummies

-Tackling dummies have evolved significantly from rag-filled bags to modern lightweight models.

-Football practice has changed over the years with safer methods replacing human contact during drills.

-Timothy Brown emphasizes the importance of using devices to reduce injuries in tackling practice.

-Innovative designs like donut-shaped dummies enhance training effectiveness and player safety during practice.

-Football archaeology highlights how equipment advancements have improved the sport's overall safety and technique.