Pigskin Dispatch

I Challenge the CFP: Is Alabama Overrated in 2026 Rankings?

By Pigskin Dispatch November 16, 2026 1 min read

I focus on the College Football Playoff rankings and the announced expansion from 12 to 24 teams, and I question whether the selection committee exhibits regional bias. I question whether the committee favors certain conferences, notably the SEC, when it ranks teams above undefeated or one-loss programs. I review the first 2026 rankings released after week 11 and describe how teams such as Georgia, Utah, Notre Dame, UCLA, Alabama, and others moved up or down. I argue that some placements, particularly a two-loss Alabama above undefeated UCLA or one-loss Notre Dame, feel unjustified. I warn that a move to 24 teams may admit teams that do not belong and could produce many lopsided outcomes, though it may also address some perceived unfairness. I invite listeners to send feedback by email or comments and say we will watch the next rankings to see how the picture develops.

Don’t forget to check out and subscribe to the Pigskin Dispatch YouTube channel for additional content and the regular Football History Minute Shorts.

Miss our football by the day of the year podcasts, well, don’t, because they can still be found at the Pigskin Dispatch website.

Come join us at the Pigskin Dispatch website and the Sports Jersey Dispatch to see even more Positive football news! Sign up to get daily football history headlines in your email inbox @ Email-subscriber

Transcript
Speaker A:

Hello, my football friends.

Speaker A:

This is Darren Hayes of pigskindispatch.com welcome once again to the Pig Pen, your portal deposit of football history.

Speaker A:

And I don't think that it's talked about quite enough.

Speaker A:

Well, maybe it is, but at least not on this program.

Speaker A:llege football rankings here,:Speaker A:

It's already been decided that it's going to move up to 24.

Speaker A:

But, but I have a question on how this College Football Playoff committee is selecting rankings for these teams.

Speaker A:had our first rankings of the:Speaker A:

That came out just before week 11 and you know, week 11 has been played and let's just go through how some of the teams have fared and then we'll discuss how this so Georgia was number one.

Speaker A:

I have no problem with that.

Speaker A:

They ended up winning comfortably against another top 25 opponent to stay firmly in that spot at number one.

Speaker A:

Utah held off a dramatic challenge from another ranked team, byu, to win that game.

Speaker A:

So they are undefeated.

Speaker A:

Number two.

Speaker A:

No problem with that.

Speaker A:

A couple problems here.

Speaker A:

Number three was Alabama last week who had came into that game at 6 2.

Speaker A:

They ended up winning comfortably at the end, but it was a little bit of a struggle in the first half.

Speaker A:

The game was in question.

Speaker A:

Two losses though for Alabama at number three.

Speaker A:

Then UCLA comes in undefeated.

Speaker A:

They stayed on top with their win and you know, beating, you know, a tough team in the Big Ten there.

Speaker A:

So they, they stayed up on top.

Speaker A:

Notre Dame at five.

Speaker A:

They improved a nine and one with a 41 to seven blowout over Boston College, while SMU, one of Notre Dame's remaining opponents, suffered a heavy loss to Wake Forest at number six.

Speaker A:

Tennessee was in a nine spot.

Speaker A:

They beat Texas A and M to get to a record of 8 and 2 despite losing their starting quarterback, George McIntyre to an injury.

Speaker A:

And freshman Faison Brandon stepping up and throwing a touchdown pass on that same drive that you know that McIntyre was lost.

Speaker A:

Texas Tech ended up winning.

Speaker A:

They were number 12.

Speaker A:

They battled number 25, Oklahoma State and Stillwater.

Speaker A:

They looked who was looking to bolster their case.

Speaker A:

And wake Forest, number 13, as we discussed, boost his playoff argument with an impressive win over smu.

Speaker A:

But there were some teams that Lost ground, You know, Kentucky, they lost to an unranked Florida team got, you know, actually got beat pretty good there.

Speaker A:

They picked up as their third loss.

Speaker A:

Then they're falling out of the playoff picture completely.

Speaker A:

University of Houston was 14.

Speaker A:

They were upset by Colorado.

Speaker A:

It opened up doors, the door for maybe a team maybe like Iowa coming in and stepping up.

Speaker A:

The Hawkeyes having a big win.

Speaker A:

LSU also dropped further down the board after another loss, effectively eliminating themselves from the College Football Playoff contention.

Speaker A:

And you have teams on the bubble like Texas Tech, Wake Forest, Iowa, Ohio State is floating out there.

Speaker A:

You know, they've lost their quarterback, lost their way a little bit.

Speaker A:

Three losses.

Speaker A:

Indiana is hanging in there.

Speaker A:

It's just a crazy, crazy look to this.

Speaker A:

So we don't know how this is going to shake out Tuesday.

Speaker A:

They're going to have the, the records come up and we're thinking, you know, it's going to be maybe something a little bit like this, you know, Georgia number one.

Speaker A:

I think Utah probably should remain number two.

Speaker A:

I believe in my heart of hearts that Notre Dame ought to be in the three spot.

Speaker A:

They're 8 and 1.

Speaker A:

They lost.

Speaker A:

Their only loss was at number eight, BYU, you know, another top 10 ranked team.

Speaker A:

I think they deserve to stand there.

Speaker A:

Knocked off number one Miami just a week ago and they held their own against Boston College the way they should be.

Speaker A:

You know, Utah, we said, you know, they should be up there in the number two spot.

Speaker A:

I think maybe Miami ought to be right behind Notre Dame and number four spot.

Speaker A:

They've had a really good go of it.

Speaker A:

UCLA should be right in there at number five.

Speaker A:

And then I think maybe Indiana deserves to be number six.

Speaker A:

Alabama at seven is where I would put them.

Speaker A:

Texas at eight, Wake Forest at nine, Tennessee Texas Tech.

Speaker A:

And maybe you bring Iowa up into that 12 spot.

Speaker A:

I know there's an argument for Boise State, possibly BYU has an argument to get in there, but it's, it's hard to say what's going to happen here.

Speaker A:

But I just think that maybe, you know, the national champion, reigning national champion Indiana Hoosiers coach Kurt Signitti has been saying that maybe there is an SEC bias here.

Speaker A:

You know, they have been putting, you know, putting a two loss Alabama team above an undefeated team in ucla, a one loss team in Notre Dame.

Speaker A:

Who knocked off the top team in the nation the week before.

Speaker A:

I don't know.

Speaker A:

There's just something that feels real wrong about that.

Speaker A:

And their argument for Alabama is that they had their strength of schedule.

Speaker A:

Well, their strength of schedule, they lost two games so should Vanderbilt, who's played all the same teams as Alabama, they have, you know, more losses than two.

Speaker A:

Should they be in the playoff picture because they had a strength of schedule?

Speaker A:

No.

Speaker A:

You want teams that win, that have a strength of schedule.

Speaker A:

And Alabama lost two games that, you know, if they want win one of those, I think their argument would be strong.

Speaker A:

But you know, you can't pick and choose just because a team is in a region that maybe that's where you're voting from and that's where your heart is.

Speaker A:

I think you got to be fair to this.

Speaker A:

I think it's the system and maybe opening up to 24 will be fairer, but you're going to have probably some teams that don't belong in the playoffs next year.

Speaker A:

24 Might be too much and there's going to be some major blowouts.

Speaker A:

We saw blowouts last year with a 12 team format in place.

Speaker A:

So I don't know.

Speaker A:

Let's get your thoughts here.

Speaker A:

Let's you know, email me at pigskind dispatch gmail.com Throw some in the comments.

Speaker A:

If you're podcast provider you're listening to this on allows that.

Speaker A:

Let's get some feedback on.

Speaker A:

Let's get some some motion on here and wait these rankings that come out here on tomorrow Tuesday to see what this picture is starting to look like.

Speaker A:

Till next time everybody have a great gridiron day.

Timeline Context

Place this dispatch in football history.

Use the Pigskin Dispatch timeline to explore surrounding events, seasons, teams, players, and eras connected to this story.

View the Timeline ↗

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *