Hailing from the steel town of Bellevue, Pennsylvania, Barrett arrived at Cornell in 1913, a raw talent yearning for the crucible of competition. Under the tutelage of Jack Moakley, he blossomed into a "real triple threat man," mesmerizing opponents with his swift runs, pinpoint passes, and bone-crunching tackles. He possessed a deceptive look – tall and slender, often mistaken for a passer. But the moment he touched the pigskin, his deceptive calm transformed into a whirlwind of athleticism.

His reign on the gridiron coincided with the golden age of the Cornell-Pennsylvania rivalry. Each fall, the gridiron became a battleground, a clash of two titans for Big Ten supremacy. And at the heart of it all stood Barrett, orchestrating victories with surgical precision and jaw-dropping displays of athleticism. His 1915 performance against Penn stands as a testament to his greatness. Trailing by nine points, he led a stunning comeback, racking up touchdowns of 40, 25, and 3 yards, and adding a drop-kick field goal and three extra points. "The Big Red Machine," they called Cornell that year, and Barrett was its engine, its relentless heartbeat.

But his story transcends touchdowns and trophies. He embodied the ideals of the scholar-athlete, excelling in the classroom as well as on the field.