The Tigers' success was built on the foundation of a powerful offensive line, anchored by players such as Frank Loney and H.W. McKee. Their ability to create holes for the running backs, including the speedy Flint, was crucial to Princeton's ground-and-pound attack. The backfield also featured James Harlan and the versatile P. Morgan, each contributing to the team's offensive firepower. The Tigers' passing game, while less emphasized than their running attack, was also effective, with players like Edward Peace and Taylor Ryan demonstrating their ability to connect on crucial plays.

The leadership of players like C.J. Winston and J.P. Withington was also instrumental in the team's success. Their experience and composure helped guide the Tigers through challenging matchups, ensuring that they remained focused on their goals. The contributions of Riggs, whose specific role is less documented, also played a part in the team's overall success. The 1880 Princeton Tigers season was a landmark achievement, a shining example of early football prowess that solidified their place as one of the game's pioneering powers.