In the 1950s and 1960s, the Black Knights adopted a helmet with a black stripe down the center, symbolizing their military heritage. This design became synonymous with the team and remained largely unchanged for several decades. However, as helmet technology advanced, the Black Knights incorporated new materials and designs to enhance player safety.

In recent years, the Black Knights have experimented with different helmet designs, including matte finishes, alternate colors, and updated logos. While these changes have generated some debate among fans, they reflect the team's commitment to staying current while honoring its traditions.