Early Flames helmets often featured a classic design with a simple Liberty Flames logo on a crimson base. As the program progressed, there was experimentation with different stripe patterns and facemask styles. In recent years, Liberty has embraced a more modern look, incorporating sleek lines and advanced technology into their helmet design. The Flames have also utilized alternate helmets for special occasions, such as matte finishes or throwback designs, adding a dynamic element to their on-field appearance.

While the helmet design has evolved, the underlying spirit of the Liberty Flames remains constant: a commitment to excellence, faith, and representing the university with pride.