Wendell's football career spanned from 1910 to 1912, a time when the sport was still evolving. Despite this, he established himself as a dominant force. Earning the prestigious title of All-American an impressive three times consecutively (1910-1912) speaks volumes about his skill. He was known for his speed, agility, and powerful tackling, a well-rounded skillset that made him a nightmare for opposing teams.

Wendell played a pivotal role in Harvard's success during his tenure. Unfortunately, detailed statistics from that era are scarce, but historical accounts paint a picture of a player who consistently elevated his team's performance.

We do know his Harvard team finished 8-0-1 that season, keeping arch rival Yale scoreless in the final game to force a tie per the National Football Foundation. "Bullet" was the star, gaining 103 yards on 21 rushes against the Elis. In the final victory of 1910, an 18-0 decision over Dartmouth, Percy had produced both of his team's touchdowns. During the 1911 season, while Wendell continued to dominate the Crimson attack, he lead the club in scoring. He drew Walter Camp's All-America selection in each of his first two years, but injuries sidelined his abilities as Harvard's senior captain in 1912.

While football was his primary focus, Wendell also excelled on the basketball court for Harvard. Though information on his basketball career is limited, his athletic prowess likely translated seamlessly onto the hardwood.

Following his graduation in 1913, Wendell transitioned into coaching. He served as head coach for several college football programs, most notably Boston University, Williams College, and Lehigh University. While his coaching record wasn't exceptional, it solidified his dedication to the sport and his desire to share his knowledge with future generations of players.

Percy Wendell's legacy may not be as widely known as some other football greats, but his accomplishments deserve recognition. He was a dominant player who helped shape the early years of college football at a prestigious institution. His impact extended beyond the field, as he continued to contribute to the sport through coaching. He serves as a reminder of the rich history of college athletics and the dedication of athletes who excelled in multiple sports.