Early Pitt helmets were simple, often featuring a single stripe or no markings at all. As the game progressed, so did helmet design. The introduction of decals allowed for more creative expression, with the Panthers experimenting with various color combinations and logos. The iconic Pitt script, a staple of the university's identity, found its way onto helmets, becoming a recognizable symbol for the program.

In recent years, Pitt has embraced a more modern aesthetic while maintaining a connection to tradition. The helmet design has become more sophisticated, incorporating advanced technology for player safety. Yet, the core elements of the Panthers' identity—the script, colors, and overall look—remain intact, ensuring a balance of tradition and innovation.