In the early days of Baylor football, helmets were more rudimentary, offering minimal protection to players. Leather helmets were the norm, and designs were often simple, with little more than a team logo or a painted stripe. Baylor's early helmets likely followed this trend, with a focus on functionality over aesthetics.

As the game of football grew more physical and safety became a greater concern, helmet designs began to evolve. The introduction of plastic shells in the 1930s marked a significant step forward, providing increased protection for players' heads. Baylor's helmets incorporated these advancements, adopting the now-familiar rounded shape that has become standard in football.